Oooooh, popovers!!

summary: popovers (Yorkshire Pudding) are insanely easy to make; (click on image(s) to see larger view and more photos)

Several weeks ago, I bemoaned the fact that I had never taken any photos of our popovers and said “I must make popovers soon!” …I did make them the following week. And again at the beginning of January. And again last night. Here at last is the proof:

popovers Back in October, Katie (Thyme For Cooking) posted Popovers – easiest bread possible! Really! I couldn’t agree with her more. They really are the easiest things to make. And SO satisfying too!

I remember almost fainting with anticipation whenever Mum made popovers. I can conjure up the aromas of the roast resting on the counter and feel how chapped my hands were from peeling all those potatoes and carrots and see Mum carving little cross patterns into the Brussels sprouts and hear the gentle clatter of silverware and good china as someone set the table.

Yes, I adore popovers! What am I saying? WE adore popovers. With way too much gravy. It doesn’t matter what kind of gravy either – roast chicken gravy, pot roast gravy, dark chocolate-chili gravy, duck à l’orange gravy – they’re all good.

So. What are popovers? Whenever I hear that question I can’t help but think of the following conversation that T reported hearing when he was motorcycling through the mid-western states on his way to Minneapolis.

Blue Kerchief Lady: [in a heavy mid-western accent (...think "Fargo")] Last night we had popovers and they were so good!

Red Kerchief Lady: [in an equally heavy mid-western accent] That’s nice. What are popovers?

Blue Kerchief Lady: Oh, my stars! You don’t know what popovers are?! Why, they’re like a big bun with air in the middle!

– overheard one morning in a small cafe in rural Minnesota

When I was growing up, Mum and Dad always called our popovers Yorkshire Pudding. It wasn’t until we were served Yorkshire Pudding at someone else’s house that I learned it was supposed to be one giant pudding rather than several small ones. I have only had it once that way… it looked pretty spectacular but some people got saddled with inside portions of the pudding that had no crispy parts.

Traditionally, Yorkshire Pudding was cooked in roasting pan in the fat thrown from the roast. But nowadays, our meat is really too lean to do that. So I use olive oil and a little butter for making popovers. (And if there happens to be any fat left over from the roast, I add that too.) And because we love the crispness of the popped part of the pudding, I always make several small Yorkshire puddings rather than one giant one.

Apparently, popovers are difficult to make. Or at least, this is what people will have you believe.

I used to think so too. I was wrong.

Perhaps I got this idea because of the popovers’ propensity to cause fires in the oven. (This really did happen a couple of times when I was growing up and was where I learned that one should always have an open box of baking soda on hand to instantly smother flames.)

To counteract this problem, instead of the muffin tins that Mum always used, I put the fat (I use olive oil and butter; Mom always used the beef fat from the Sunday roast) into pyrex dishes placed on a jelly roll sheet to ensure that any oil spitting out goes onto the sheet instead of the bottom of the oven and/or element.

Now that fear of fires is gone, for me, the most difficult thing about making popovers is to remember to get egg and milk to room temperature. If I haven’t planned ahead, I can do this the quick way, of course: put the egg (shell on still) and milk (in its measuring container) into a very warm water bath until they are no longer fridge cold.

Unlike many other popover cooks (I learned the method I use from my mom – who learned it from her mom, who learned it from her mom, etc. etc.), I put zero fat into the batter itself. Instead, as I’m whisking the eggs, I always preheat the fat into small pyrex bowls or muffin tins and put the bowls onto a jelly roll pan in a hot oven til the fat is very very very hot. So hot that the popover batter bubbles and sizzles as it is poured into the hot oil. The times that I have not done this, the popovers have not puffed.

whisk eggs The other things that seem to be required are:

  1. Beat the eggs, milk and salt with a whisk until the mixture is light coloured and frothy. This should be done BEFORE adding any flour
  2. Fill the baking container(s) to no more than half full.
  3. Leave the oven door closed until the pudding is well puffed! Otherwise, the pudding will fall. It’s safe to turn the tray around, to account for uneven oven heat, at about the 20 minute mark.

popover Popovers should be served immediately after coming out of the oven. With LOTS of gravy. Too much gravy. (Here, when the photo was taken, I hadn’t yet finished pouring in the orange gravy from roast chicken a l’orange.)

Great minds think alike! The recent SAVEUR 100 featured A World of Whisks!

whisk [The coil whisk] is now my favourite whisk for beating eggs! It’s light-weight, very fast and really easy to use. Not to mention that it’s a breeze to wash. Even without the aid of an electronic dishwasher…. I can’t wait to see how well it works for making popovers!

-me, “How many whisks does one kitchen need?”, blog from OUR kitchen

Ha! I only used it only for a second! It really doesn’t work in a big bowl. (It’s fantastic and still the best one for beating an egg in a pyrex cup measure.) The ball whisk and the broken whisk with the white handle are the best for whisking the egg for popovers.





This entry was posted in equipment and techniques, food & drink, side on by .

* Thank you for visiting. Even though I may not get a chance to reply to you directly, I love seeing your responses and/or questions and read each and every one of them. Please note that your e-mail address will never be displayed on this site, nor will it ever be shared.

"Moderation" is in use. It may take a little time before your response appears. Responses containing unsolicited advertising will be deleted as spam (which means any subsequent attempts will be automatically relegated to the spam section and unlikely to be retrieved). For further information, please read the Discussion Policy.

2 responses to “Oooooh, popovers!!

  1. MyKitchenInHalfCups

    Um, we’re so different. I learned from my Dad. We always have them for breakfast with butter, jams and fruit, NEVER gravy – ok gravy once at a friend’s as Yorkshire Pudding. BUT, at least we’re alike in our love for them ;-)

    With jam and butter!? Whoa! I can’t even imagine how that would be. I mean really. Popovers MUST be eaten with gravy! :-) -ejm (what kind of jam?)

  2. Sandie

    I love popovers with gravy and also with butter and jam. It just depends on what time of day! They are great with strawberry butter and honey at brunch…


Leave a Reply to Sandie Cancel reply

You must fill in the "response", "name", and "email" fields. Please rest assured that your email address will never be posted or shared. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam; learn how your discussion data is processed. Please note that the optional fields that point to your website URL and website name may be removed without notice. For more information about what can (or cannot) be included, please read the Discussion Policy.